|
To
judge a fund fairly, its performance must be weighed against its peers -
in other words, comparing "apples to apples." If Fund "A"
gained 3% in a month, while Fund "B" gained just 1.5%, can we
conclude that "A" is superior to "B"? Not necessarily.
If "A" exposed us to far greater risk of loss to achieve a slightly
higher return, it wouldn't be fair to compare the two.
Funds
can be grouped into dozens of possible categories (international, large
value, small growth, single country funds, just to name a few). We've
chosen to categorize funds according to risk. To streamline the decision-making
process, we arrived at four risk classes for equity funds. Bond funds
are grouped into a fifth class.
Using
broad categories means we have a full range of investment opportunities
available to us. For instance, rather than isolating international funds
from domestic, we group them with others with similar downside risk. This
allows the best to rise to the top, whatever their investment approach
might be. There is some overlap; occasionally you may find a Class 2 fund
showing no more volatility than a typical Class 3 fund, for example. But
overall the classifications provide a realistic indication of what we
might expect from a fund.
Occasionally,
we reclassify funds when new information indicates a change is in order.
Some funds are moving targets, with shifting investment styles. Even funds
with consistent styles may experience unexpected volatility during various
market cycles.
Our
analysis involves assessing a variety of quantitative measures of risk,
in addition to questioning portfolio managers, examining investment holdings
and surveying independent reporting services.
Class 1: Growth - Most Speculative Stock Funds
Includes
funds that focus on special investments such as gold, precious metals
or natural resources, specific industries or market sectors. May invest
in small, new and unseasoned companies (micro- and Small-Cap). May have
very high portfolio turnover. International funds may concentrate in a
particular country or region, including "emerging markets" or
economies not considered mature. May use investing techniques such as
leveraging, margin, short positions or use of derivative instruments such
as options or futures in ways likely to increase volatility.
High potential returns concurrent with high possibility of loss.
Class 2: Growth - Speculative Stock Funds
Includes
funds invested in small or mid-sized companies. May lack diversification
by focusing on a few industry sectors or concentrating portfolio in a
few individual holdings. Mostly common stocks, but may contain convertible
bonds or other instruments. May have moderate to high portfolio turnover.
High potential returns with higher-than-average volatility or price
fluctuation.
Class 3: Growth - Higher Quality Stock Funds
THIS
IS OUR RECOMMENDED CLASS
Comprised
of diversified portfolios invested in well-established companies. Portfolios
may include some fixed-income instruments such as bonds, convertibles,
preferred stock or cash. May have flexibility to move to large cash positions.
International (foreign) or global (foreign and domestic) funds tend to
invest in larger companies in mature economies (e.g., Europe & Japan).
Primary objectives are long-term growth with little emphasis on income.
With a wide variety of styles represented, the funds do not move in tandem.
As a group, they present about the same level of risk as a broad stock
market index like the S&P 500 or the Wilshire 5000.
Class 4: Total Return or Balanced Funds
Includes
wide variety of investment strategies, usually including common stocks.
Often hold income-generating instruments to lower portfolio volatility.
These not limited to: corporate or government bonds, convertible bonds,
preferred stock, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs), repurchase agreements
and other money market instruments, or the sale of call options. May focus
on high dividend-paying stocks (e.g., utilities companies). May use derivative
instruments specifically to lessen volatility, such as futures, put options
or short selling. Some portfolios might follow predetermined asset allocations;
others may diversify among asset classes at manager's discretion. Primary
objectives are moderate long-term growth with income.
Class 5: Income - Bonds, Notes, Money Market
Instruments
Primary
objective is current income and preservation of capital. This class is
divided into three sections:
Corporate:
Includes funds invested in corporate debt ranging in credit quality. May
include commercial paper, convertible debentures, some money market instruments.
Possible limited use of common stocks.
Government:
Bonds issued or backed by the U.S. Government or its agencies. Includes
U.S. Treasury bonds, notes and bills; debt issued by FNMA (Fannie Mae),
FHLMC (Freddie Mac), GNMA (Ginnie Mae); repurchase agreements backed by
U.S. Treasury securities.
Municipal:
Bonds issued by state or local municipalities. Income is usually exempt
from Federal income tax. Income from state bonds is generally exempt from
income taxes for that state's residents. Capital gains realized when a
fund is sold are taxable.
Bond funds are further segregated by average maturity:
Short-Term:
Between 0 and 4 years
Intermediate-Term: Between 4 and 10 years
Long-Term: Between 10 and 25 years
Flexible: Maturities vary at manager discretion.
High-Yield: Focus on bonds of low credit quality. These funds offer
higher income yield and potential gain, but increased default risk results
in greater volatility.
|